Curlys Pizza & Subs in Lima has earned its reputation as one of the best local spots for authentic Italian-American comfort food. Known for its fresh, made-from-scratch pizzas, subs, pastas, and even desserts, Curlys delivers both flavor and value. With a consistent 4.7-star rating, it’s the go-to choice for families, students, and anyone craving hearty portions with unbeatable taste.
Services
- Freshly prepared pizza, subs, and pasta made daily.
- Desserts and cakes baked from scratch.
- Convenient delivery and pickup options through DoorDash.
- Lunch and dinner hours with flexible ordering times.
- Affordable prices with large portion sizes that feed families easily.
Menu Highlights
- The Classic Pizza – Generous toppings and perfectly balanced cheese-to-sauce ratio.
- Build Your Own Pizza – Choose your size and load it up with as many toppings as you like.
- Deluxe Pizza – A favorite with loaded meats, veggies, and Curlys’ signature crust.
- Cheesy Garlic Breadsticks – Buttery, soft, and overflowing with cheese.
- Subs & Calzones – Oven-baked, stuffed, and full of flavor.
- Homemade Pasta Dishes – Pair with meatballs or cheesy bread for a full meal.
- Desserts – Cakes and sweets crafted in-house to finish your meal right.
Pros
- Known as the best pizza in Lima by loyal customers.
- Crispy yet soft crust with no skimping on toppings.
- Friendly, reliable service with attention to special requests.
- Great prices considering the portion sizes and freshness.
- Perfect for family meals, gatherings, or quick takeout.
Reviews
Review 1 – Misty P (March 2025):
“Best pizza in Lima! Great prices for the amount of food. Tons of toppings and cheese. Fed my large family with leftovers to spare.”
Review 2 – Tom M (Feb 2024):
“HANDS DOWN the best in town. Crispy crust, loaded toppings, and perfect flavor. Curlys has a new faithful customer—try it and you’ll see.”
Review 3 – Katey D (April 2024):
“Pizza came with generous toppings and our special request was done perfectly. Cheesy breadsticks with buttery garlic sauce were amazing.”
Review 4 – Chris S (June 2024):
“Got the 10-inch Deluxe and loved it! Breadsticks with cheese dip and pizza sauce paired so well. Next time, I’m going for the 18-inch.”
Review 5 – Melissa S (Oct 2023):
“The pizza is really good! Cheese was perfect, meats were flavorful, and the sausage stood out. Will definitely be back.”