Mayfair Gardens is a thoughtfully designed apartment community located in the heart of Commack, Long Island. Known for its balance of modern amenities and a peaceful suburban atmosphere, this property appeals to individuals, couples, and small families seeking a comfortable lifestyle with easy access to city conveniences.
Built in 2002, Mayfair Gardens consists of 107 well-maintained units across two stories, featuring studio, one-, and two-bedroom floor plans ranging from 400 to 900 square feet.
This pet-friendly community emphasizes convenience and accessibility. Residents enjoy being close to shopping centers, public transportation, top-rated schools, and recreational areas like Hoyt Farm Nature Preserve and the Hamlet Golf & Country Club.
With utilities such as heat, gas, water, and trash removal included in rent, Mayfair Gardens provides excellent value for Long Island living.
Services
• Studio, 1-, and 2-bedroom apartments (400–900 sq. ft.)
• 12-month lease terms (no short-term leases)
• Heat, gas, water, and trash removal included
• Air conditioning and heating in every unit
• Granite countertops and stainless-steel appliances
• Hardwood flooring and crown molding details
• On-site laundry facilities
• High-speed internet and cable-ready units
• Courtyard and landscaped garden areas
• Maintenance on-site and responsive management
• Tours by appointment only
Pros
• Excellent location: Situated near schools, shops, and entertainment in the desirable Commack area.
• Modern finishes: Apartments feature granite countertops, hardwood floors, and stainless-steel appliances.
• Convenience: Utilities included simplify monthly expenses, and the property offers easy access to major highways.
• Quiet suburban setting: Surrounded by parks and natural spaces, perfect for families and professionals seeking calm living.
• No broker or application surprises: Transparent rental process with no broker fees and clear leasing criteria.
Reviews
- “The apartments are clean and modern, but communication with management could be better. Maintenance requests take time.” – Resident (2024)
- “Great location near everything in Commack, but the rent is a bit high for the space offered.” – Resident (2023)
- “The property is quiet and well-kept. I like that heat and water are included—it makes budgeting easier.” – Resident (2022)
- “My experience was mixed. The apartment itself is nice, but management sometimes feels unresponsive. Still, overall, it’s a good value.” – Resident (2021)
- “No broker fee and move-in was straightforward. The area feels safe, and neighbors are respectful.” – Resident (2020)
Mayfair Gardens combines the charm of Long Island’s suburban living with the convenience of modern apartment amenities. Ideal for those who value accessibility, comfort, and a well-connected community, it remains a solid housing choice for professionals, students, and small families looking for a peaceful place to call home in Commack, NY.